I have never
been a fan of using English as a primary language of communication in a movie
that is set in a country where English is not a first language; even more so, in
a period drama. To me, that is where The
Zookeeper’s falls short. There is a dialogue
in the second half that made me cringe. When Antonina Zabinski (Jessica
Chastain) tells Urszula (Shira Haas), “I have always wanthed tu dhraw”.
Mind you, I understand
the need to be able to connect with a vast majority of the audiences and surely
Polish (the language and not the product) is not widely spoken. But the nuances of a language cannot be done
justice to – even with the best of translators.
If you do want to make the movie in English, then please make it in
English by all means. Don’t force an
accent.
Having said
that, The Zookeeper’s Wife makes the cut on almost all other counts. The aversion to the use of English is a
personal preference and may not be the case with most viewers. Antonina and Jan (Johan Heldenberg) are
keepers of the Warsaw Zoo which boasts of some of the best animals before Hitler
decided that Poland was up for grabs. They
lived there with their son Ryszard (Timothy Radford) when the Fuhrer made
himself feel at home.
An air strike leaves
the Zoo in disarray. The keepers are in
shock but life has to go on. Disturbed
by the possibility of losing those that they have grown up with – Jews and Gentiles
alike – the couple decide to provide refuge to their closest friend Magda (Efrat
Dor).
However, with
the way things shape up, Jan and Antonina decide that they need to do much more
and that’s where the true story of the Zookeepers begins. Over a 5 year period,
Jan and Nina provided safe stay and passage to nearly 300 Jews for which they
received the gratitude of the Israeli government. A story that definitely
needed to be told – one of many, I am certain, that have not seen the light of
day yet.
Like any movie that
touches upon the Holocaust, The Zookeeper’s Wife, will leave you poignant. I am sure that no one in our generation can
even imagine what it was like to be dragged out of your homes and shot for no
reason – and that’s if you were lucky.
Jessica Chastain
does as well as she possibly can. With
the limitations of the accent imposed by director Niki Caro, I guess it was as
good as she could get. Needless to say,
it was a far cry from Chastain’s best performances to date such as Interstellar,
ZD30 and of course The Help.
The stand out
performance though comes from Daniel Bruhl who I believe is one of THE most
underrated actors of our time. The
support cast is solid and the production quality is par excellence. Scenes such as the delivery of the Elephant
Calf or that of Adam (the camel) running after Nina during her morning rounds
are superbly shot.
In all, The
Zookeeper’s Wife – and I wonder why it wasn’t just called The Zookeepers –
considering that Jan’s role in the effort of saving the Jews was as important
if not better – is a good watch for a Sunday afternoon at home. Would I spend hard earned money to walk into
a theatre? Probably not. 6 on 10. Worth a dekko.
Watch the
trailer on http://www.imdb.com/video/imdb/vi2949821977
I sure can imagine what it was like to be dragged out of your homes and shot for no reason. Have lived through it. Do read about the Kashmiri Pandit Exodus. You could perhaps begin with : http://www.dimplehere.com/kpexodus-genocide-denial-junaid-mattu-massacre-of-pandits/
ReplyDeleteHey keep posting such good and meaningful articles.
ReplyDeleteAwesome work.Just wanted to drop a comment and say I am new to your blog and really like what I am reading.Thanks for the share
ReplyDelete